Explore illusions.im

motion.illusions.im

The waterfall that makes the rocks rise.

In 1834 Robert Addams looked at the falling water at the Falls of Foyers, then at the rocks beside it. The rocks seemed to move upwards. That motion aftereffect is the signature of this site, with a desk you can try, and a careful look at induced movement, autokinetic drift, and a few other kinds of apparent motion — every claim sourced.

A tall white waterfall dropping down a dark rocky face into a pool, with trees on either side
The Falls of Foyers, on the River Foyers near Loch Ness, photographed by Zenit on 4 July 2009. This is the cascade Robert Addams named in 1834, after he had looked at the falling water and then at the rocks beside it. A Commons file caption mentions “a fall of 165 feet”; that figure is not taken from Addams’s paper, and is not repeated here as a fact. Photo: Zenit · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The waterfall that makes the rocks rise

Pick a story. In 1834 Robert Addams looked at the falling water at the Falls of Foyers, then at the rocks beside it — and the rocks seemed to move upwards. Encyclopaedia Britannica still uses everyday scenes, a parade, a train window, a star in the dark, to explain the same family of apparent motions.

Encyclopaedia Britannica describes the same aftereffect with a familiar scene: after you have watched a parade go by, the pavement may seem to move in the opposite direction to the marchers. The usual official account is fatigue in detectors that respond to one direction of motion, so the opposite direction is briefly over-represented. Official wording keeps that account as something that “probably” arises. This desk keeps the “probably” too. [source]

Addams’s account, published in 1834, is the classic version of the same aftereffect. The wording is public domain, and is quoted in full on the Foyers page. [source]

A nineteenth-century albumen photograph of a waterfall in a wooded gorge, with rocks in the foreground
The Falls of Foyers, an albumen print by George Washington Wilson, made about 1858 to 1868. The image is cropped to the photograph as it was mounted in a Rijksmuseum album (object RP-F-2001-7-1092-29); the surrounding album page is not shown here. Public domain / CC0. Photograph (cropped to the mounted print): George Washington Wilson. Rijksmuseum, RP-F-2001-7-1092-29 · CC0 · Rijksmuseum / Wikimedia Commons

Around that aftereffect sits a small family. Induced movement is the appearance of movement in a still object when its frame moves — a train seen through a window is the official everyday case. The autokinetic effect is a small, steady light in darkness that seems to wander; Alexander von Humboldt described it in 1799, watching a star through a telescope. Very slow movement, official wording says, is about that of the minute hand on a watch. Under flickering light, a fan or a wheel can seem to turn slowly or even backward, and stagecoach wheels may do the same in the cinema. Film toys and the wagon-wheel effect on a screen are reserved here for a planned sister site, so they are not mixed up with the rocks that only seemed to rise.

Keep the lights on

Enjoyed this desk of motion that is not quite there?

No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next illusions.im site get built.