Explore illusions.im

Home · Kinds

A small family

Kinds of apparent motion

The waterfall aftereffect is one member of a small family. Encyclopaedia Britannica’s article on movement perception is the source for the kinds collected here. Film toys and the wagon-wheel effect on a screen are mentioned only so they are not mixed up with the rocks that only seemed to rise. [source]

A U.S. Army band in campaign hats marching in a street parade, some players waving, with a 1st Cavalry Division sign behind them
The 1st Cavalry Division Band in a parade at the Bolesławiec ceramic festival, Poland, on 16 August 2024, photographed by Staff Sgt. Jasmine McCarthy. Encyclopaedia Britannica uses a parade as an example of the motion aftereffect: after the marchers have gone by, the pavement may seem to move the other way. This photograph is of a parade. It is not a picture of the aftereffect itself. Public domain, U.S. Army. Photo: Staff Sgt. Jasmine McCarthy, U.S. Army · Public domain · U.S. Army / Wikimedia Commons

The motion aftereffect

Official wording gives a scene almost anyone can picture: “When a parade is interrupted after some minutes, the pavement may seem to move in the opposite direction to the marchers who have passed.” The photograph on this page is of a parade — the 1st Cavalry Division Band at Bolesławiec, on 16 August 2024. It is not a picture of the aftereffect itself. The official explanation is careful: the aftereffect “probably arises when movement detectors in the brain that respond to the original direction of motion become fatigued, leaving predominant those detectors that respond to contrary movement.” This desk keeps that “probably.”

Induced movement

Sometimes it is not the thing you are looking at that moves, but the frame around it. Official wording: if a small object is presented in a frame with nothing else in view, movement is usually attributed to the object even when only the frame moves. A larger surround is accepted as the stable frame. The everyday case is a train seen through a window: “the illusion that your train is moving when it is really the moving train alongside that, seen through the window, is falsely accepted as the frame of reference.”

A blue, white and yellow British Rail Class 378 train standing at Richmond station in London, with another train under the canopy to the right
British Rail Class 378 unit 378010 at Richmond station, London, on 8 October 2009, photographed by Jim Linwood. Encyclopaedia Britannica’s example of induced movement is a train seen through a window, when a neighbouring train starts to move. This photograph shows a train at a platform. It does not itself show two trains in motion. Photo: Jim Linwood · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The autokinetic effect

A small, steady light in a dark, featureless surroundings can appear to wander, even though it is not moving. Official wording says Alexander von Humboldt described the effect in 1799, watching a star through a telescope, and attributed the motion to the star itself. About sixty years later it was shown to be subjective, apparently arising from instability in the sense of eye position without a visual frame of reference. “About sixty years later” is kept as written. A more precise year is not invented here.

Very slow movement, and a flickering light

Official wording places very slow movement at about that of the minute hand on a watch. Under flickering or interrupted light, a rotating fan, or a wheel, can seem to turn more slowly, or even backward. “Stagecoach wheels may seem to move backward in the cinema.” That cinema case is mentioned so it is not mixed up with the aftereffect. The toys and film devices that use similar timing belong with the planned sister site moving-pictures.illusions.im.

A nineteenth-century four-wheeled dog-cart game wagon, seen from the side, with large wooden spoked wheels
A four-wheel dog-cart game wagon made by Brewster & Co. in 1878, from the Metropolitan Museum of Art (accession 3401). Official wording notes that stagecoach wheels may seem to move backward in the cinema. This photograph is of a historic wagon and its wheels. It is not a picture of that cinema effect. Public domain / CC0. Photo: Metropolitan Museum of Art. Brewster & Co., 1878 · CC0 · Metropolitan Museum of Art / Wikimedia Commons
Keep the lights on

Enjoyed this desk of motion that is not quite there?

No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next illusions.im site get built.