Explore illusions.im

Questions

Questions people ask

Short answers, in the wording of the official pages used on this site, and a few practical notes about the desk and the downloads.

What is the waterfall illusion on this site?

It is the motion aftereffect Robert Addams described at the Falls of Foyers in 1834: after looking at falling water, the neighbouring rocks seemed to move upwards. Encyclopaedia Britannica describes the same kind of aftereffect with a parade and a pavement. [source] [source]

Does the waterfall desk work for everyone?

No, and it does not need to. Many people see a gentle upward drift after the falling stripes; some do not, or not every time. The desk is a demonstration, not a test of eyesight. If your system asks for reduced motion, the animation stays off and the idea is given in words.

Is induced movement the same as the aftereffect?

Official wording treats them as different members of a family. In the aftereffect, you have been watching motion in one direction, and a still surface then seems to move the other way. In induced movement, a still thing seems to move because its frame is moving now — a neighbouring train, seen through a window, is the official everyday case. [source]

Did Humboldt see a star move?

Official wording says that in 1799 he watched a star through a telescope and attributed movement to the star itself. About sixty years later the autokinetic effect was shown to be subjective. This site keeps those two official moments apart. [source]

How high are the Falls of Foyers?

This site does not state a height. Addams’s quoted paragraph does not give one. A Commons file caption mentions “a fall of 165 feet,” and that figure stays with the file. [source]

Why are there so many photographs of the same waterfall?

Because the place is the official setting of the 1834 account. A mid-nineteenth-century print and several modern views show the fall without pretending to reconstruct Addams’s visit, or to measure the cascade from a file caption.

Why is there a wagon, and a fan, on a site about a waterfall?

Official wording mentions very slow movement at about the speed of a minute hand, a rotating fan under flickering light, and stagecoach wheels that may seem to move backward in the cinema. The photographs introduce those official examples. They do not show the effects themselves.

Where do zoetropes and flip books belong?

With the planned sister site moving-pictures.illusions.im. They are named here so they are not treated as this site’s centrepiece.

Can I print something?

Yes. Three typographic fact sheets, in A4 and US Letter, are free on the downloads page. They contain no photographs.

Is this site affiliated with Encyclopaedia Britannica?

No. motion.illusions.im is independent, and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Encyclopaedia Britannica, the Illusions Index, or the museums and photographers named in the credits. Their names identify the records quoted.

Keep the lights on

Enjoyed this desk of motion that is not quite there?

No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next illusions.im site get built.