Explore illusions.im

Myths versus facts

Checked claims

A few claims that are easy to pick up, and the official wording that answers them. Photographs on this site introduce official examples. They do not, by themselves, show the illusions.

A close view of a standing electric fan with a metal cage and three blades
An electric fan, photographed by Garonzi Stefania on 7 February 2019. Encyclopaedia Britannica mentions a rotating fan, under flickering light, among stroboscopic effects. This still shows a fan at rest. It is not a photograph of those effects. Used on the website only, under CC BY-SA 4.0, and not placed in the typographic fact sheets. Photo: Garonzi Stefania · CC BY-SA 4.0 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons

The rocks at Foyers were really rising.

They were not. Addams was clear that he had seen “this singular deception” after looking at the descending water. The apparent upward motion was in his view of a still rock face. [source]

The parade photograph shows the aftereffect.

It shows a parade. Encyclopaedia Britannica’s example is what you may see after the marchers have gone by — the pavement seeming to move the other way. A photograph of a band in the street cannot show that aftereffect. [source]

The official explanation is a settled law.

Official wording says the aftereffect “probably arises” from fatigue in one set of movement detectors. This desk keeps the “probably,” and does not harden it into a certainty the source does not claim. [source]

The Richmond photograph shows two trains in motion.

It shows a train standing at a platform, with another train under the canopy. It introduces the official train-window example of induced movement. It does not itself show the illusion. [source]

If your own train seems to move, you are experiencing the waterfall aftereffect.

Not necessarily. Official wording treats induced movement as a different member of the family: a still thing seems to move because its frame is moving now, not because you have just been watching motion in one direction. [source]

Humboldt already knew the wandering star was only in his eyes.

Official wording says he attributed the movement to the star itself in 1799. About sixty years later the effect was shown to be subjective. The later finding is not read back into his official first account. [source]

The night-sky photograph shows the autokinetic effect.

It shows stars above a forest. Official wording describes an isolated point of light in the dark, reported as moving when it is not. A still of a night sky is not a picture of that effect. [source]

The Falls of Foyers are officially 165 feet high on this site.

A Commons file caption mentions “a fall of 165 feet.” That figure is not taken from Addams’s paper, and is not repeated here as a fact. [source]

The waterfall desk is a test of your eyesight.

It is a short demonstration. Some people notice an upward drift; some do not, or not every time. That is ordinary, and is not treated as a diagnosis. [source]

This site’s centrepiece is the wagon-wheel effect on film.

Official wording does mention that stagecoach wheels may seem to move backward in the cinema. Film toys, phi, and the wagon-wheel effect on a screen are reserved here for a planned sister site, so they are not mixed up with the aftereffect. [source]

The historic wagon is a stagecoach in the official sense.

It is a four-wheel dog-cart game wagon made by Brewster & Co. in 1878. Official wording about stagecoach wheels stays with the cinema example. The vehicle is not relabelled to force a closer match. [source]

A later magazine retelling can stand in for Addams’s words.

It cannot, on this site. The Foyers paragraph is quoted from the 1834 paper. A commonly shortened form, or a secondary paraphrase, is not used in its place. [source]

Keep the lights on

Enjoyed this desk of motion that is not quite there?

No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next illusions.im site get built.