Each story is taken from Addams’s 1834 wording, from Encyclopaedia Britannica’s article on movement perception, or from a clearly dated, licence-checked photograph caption. Nothing here is invented, and a legend is not promoted into a fact.
After a few seconds at the cascade, Addams looked left at the sombre age-worn rocks. They seemed to move upwards at the speed of the descending water — a “singular deception.”
The Falls of Foyers, on the River Foyers near Loch Ness, photographed by Zenit on 4 July 2009. This is the cascade Robert Addams named in 1834, after he had looked at the falling water and then at the rocks beside it. A Commons file caption mentions “a fall of 165 feet”; that figure is not taken from Addams’s paper, and is not repeated here as a fact.Photo: Zenit · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons
Addams did not only name the fall. He admired “the confluence and decussation of the currents forming the liquid drapery of waters,” and then looked away. The official wording keeps both the beauty and the trick.
The Falls of Foyers, an albumen print by George Washington Wilson, made about 1858 to 1868. The image is cropped to the photograph as it was mounted in a Rijksmuseum album (object RP-F-2001-7-1092-29); the surrounding album page is not shown here. Public domain / CC0.Photograph (cropped to the mounted print): George Washington Wilson. Rijksmuseum, RP-F-2001-7-1092-29 · CC0 · Rijksmuseum / Wikimedia Commons
Official wording: after a parade has gone by, the pavement may seem to move in the opposite direction to the marchers. A photograph of a band is a photograph of a parade, not of that aftereffect.
The 1st Cavalry Division Band in a parade at the Bolesławiec ceramic festival, Poland, on 16 August 2024, photographed by Staff Sgt. Jasmine McCarthy. Encyclopaedia Britannica uses a parade as an example of the motion aftereffect: after the marchers have gone by, the pavement may seem to move the other way. This photograph is of a parade. It is not a picture of the aftereffect itself. Public domain, U.S. Army.Photo: Staff Sgt. Jasmine McCarthy, U.S. Army · Public domain · U.S. Army / Wikimedia Commons
The usual official account is that detectors for one direction of motion become fatigued, so the opposite direction briefly has the upper hand. The official word is “probably.” This desk keeps it.
The Fall of Foyers, photographed by CrlNvl on 19 July 2017. The file describes it as a waterfall on the River Foyers, which feeds Loch Ness, in Highland, Scotland. Used on the website only, under CC BY-SA 4.0, and not placed in the typographic fact sheets.Photo: CrlNvl · CC BY-SA 4.0 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons
When a neighbouring train starts, official wording says your own carriage can seem to move the other way — the window has falsely accepted a new frame of reference.
British Rail Class 378 unit 378010 at Richmond station, London, on 8 October 2009, photographed by Jim Linwood. Encyclopaedia Britannica’s example of induced movement is a train seen through a window, when a neighbouring train starts to move. This photograph shows a train at a platform. It does not itself show two trains in motion.Photo: Jim Linwood · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons
A Midland Main Line landscape, photographed from a train window, is a view through a frame. It introduces the official example. It is not a picture of the illusion itself.
A Midland Main Line landscape photographed from a train window by James Petts on 5 October 2017. Official wording on induced movement uses a train seen through a window as the everyday case. This still is a view from a window. It is not a photograph of the illusion itself. Used on the website only, under CC BY-SA 2.0, and not placed in the typographic fact sheets.Photo: James Petts · CC BY-SA 2.0 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons
In 1799, official wording says, Alexander von Humboldt watched a star through a telescope and attributed its wandering to the star itself. That is the autokinetic effect, before it had a common name.
Alexander von Humboldt, painted in 1806 by Friedrich Georg Weitsch. This is a photograph of the canvas in the Alte Nationalgalerie, Berlin, by Wuselig. Official wording says Humboldt described the autokinetic effect in 1799, watching a star through a telescope. The painting is a portrait. It is not a picture of that observation. Public domain.Painting (photograph of the canvas): Friedrich Georg Weitsch, 1806. Photograph: Wuselig, Alte Nationalgalerie · Public domain · Alte Nationalgalerie / Wikimedia Commons
Official wording says the autokinetic effect was later shown to be subjective, apparently from instability in the sense of eye position without a visual frame. “About sixty years later” is kept as written.
Stars in the night sky above the boreal forest at Chisasibi, Quebec, photographed by Carl Young on 17 September 2019. Official wording says Alexander von Humboldt described the autokinetic effect in 1799 while watching a star through a telescope. This is a photograph of a night sky. It is not a picture of that effect, and it is not a claim that Humboldt was looking at these stars. Used on the website only, under CC BY-SA 4.0, and not placed in the typographic fact sheets.Photo: Carl Young · CC BY-SA 4.0 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons
Very slow movement, official wording says, is about that of the minute hand on a watch. This desk does not invent a more precise official speed.
A four-wheel dog-cart game wagon made by Brewster & Co. in 1878, from the Metropolitan Museum of Art (accession 3401). Official wording notes that stagecoach wheels may seem to move backward in the cinema. This photograph is of a historic wagon and its wheels. It is not a picture of that cinema effect. Public domain / CC0.Photo: Metropolitan Museum of Art. Brewster & Co., 1878 · CC0 · Metropolitan Museum of Art / Wikimedia Commons
Official wording says stagecoach wheels may seem to move backward in the cinema. A historic wagon on this site is a wagon. It is not a still from that cinema effect.
A four-wheel dog-cart game wagon made by Brewster & Co. in 1878, from the Metropolitan Museum of Art (accession 3401). Official wording notes that stagecoach wheels may seem to move backward in the cinema. This photograph is of a historic wagon and its wheels. It is not a picture of that cinema effect. Public domain / CC0.Photo: Metropolitan Museum of Art. Brewster & Co., 1878 · CC0 · Metropolitan Museum of Art / Wikimedia Commons
Under flickering light, official wording mentions a rotating fan among stroboscopic effects. A photograph of a fan at rest is a photograph of a fan, not of those effects.
An electric fan, photographed by Garonzi Stefania on 7 February 2019. Encyclopaedia Britannica mentions a rotating fan, under flickering light, among stroboscopic effects. This still shows a fan at rest. It is not a photograph of those effects. Used on the website only, under CC BY-SA 4.0, and not placed in the typographic fact sheets.Photo: Garonzi Stefania · CC BY-SA 4.0 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons
A Commons file mentions “a fall of 165 feet” at Foyers. That figure stays with the file. It is not taken from the 1834 paper, and is not repeated here as a fact.
The Falls of Foyers near Loch Ness, photographed by Banja-Frans Mulder on 3 August 2015. The file title is “Scotland, Falls of Foyers near Loch Ness.” This is a modern view of the place Addams named; it is not a reconstruction of his visit.Photo: Banja-Frans Mulder · CC BY 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons
George Washington Wilson photographed the Falls of Foyers about 1858 to 1868. The still used here is cropped to the mounted print in a Rijksmuseum album; the album page itself is not shown.
The Falls of Foyers, an albumen print by George Washington Wilson, made about 1858 to 1868. The image is cropped to the photograph as it was mounted in a Rijksmuseum album (object RP-F-2001-7-1092-29); the surrounding album page is not shown here. Public domain / CC0.Photograph (cropped to the mounted print): George Washington Wilson. Rijksmuseum, RP-F-2001-7-1092-29 · CC0 · Rijksmuseum / Wikimedia Commons
The waterfall desk is an original downward-stripe demonstration, with a fixation mark and a still test field. It is not a copy of anyone else’s animation, and it is not a test of your eyesight.
The Falls of Foyers, photographed by Pjt56 on 13 June 2017. File title: “Falls of Foyers, Scotland.” Used on the website only, under CC BY-SA 4.0, and not placed in the typographic fact sheets.Photo: Pjt56 · CC BY-SA 4.0 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons
Zoetropes, flip books, phi as cinema, and the wagon-wheel effect on a screen belong with the planned sister site moving-pictures.illusions.im. They are named here so they are not stolen as this site’s centrepiece.
An electric fan, photographed by Garonzi Stefania on 7 February 2019. Encyclopaedia Britannica mentions a rotating fan, under flickering light, among stroboscopic effects. This still shows a fan at rest. It is not a photograph of those effects. Used on the website only, under CC BY-SA 4.0, and not placed in the typographic fact sheets.Photo: Garonzi Stefania · CC BY-SA 4.0 (website only) · Wikimedia Commons
Weitsch painted Humboldt in 1806. The canvas in the Alte Nationalgalerie is a portrait. The official 1799 observation of a wandering star is a separate, earlier official fact.
Alexander von Humboldt, painted in 1806 by Friedrich Georg Weitsch. This is a photograph of the canvas in the Alte Nationalgalerie, Berlin, by Wuselig. Official wording says Humboldt described the autokinetic effect in 1799, watching a star through a telescope. The painting is a portrait. It is not a picture of that observation. Public domain.Painting (photograph of the canvas): Friedrich Georg Weitsch, 1806. Photograph: Wuselig, Alte Nationalgalerie · Public domain · Alte Nationalgalerie / Wikimedia CommonsKeep the lights on
Enjoyed this desk of motion that is not quite there?
No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next illusions.im site get built.